The Auston Matthews next team odds market has been heating up since reports surfaced that the Toronto Maple Leafs captain wanted to see what management would do in the off-season before committing to playing out the remaining two years of his contract. There has been somewhat of a mass exodus of American players leaving Canadian markets for US-based teams, with recent examples like Brady Tkachuk in Ottawa and Quinn Hughes in Vancouver.
Auston Matthews Next Team Odds: The Most Likely Landing Spots for the Maple Leafs Captain
- The betting favorites in the Auston Matthews next team odds
- Matthews in Southern California?
- Who could Toronto target in a Matthews trade?
John E. Sokolowski-Imagn Images
Auston Matthews is the first US-born captain in Maple Leafs history, following legends like Mats Sundin and John Tavares. No Leafs captain in the salary-cap era has ever been traded while actively wearing the "C."
Matthews was once a perennial contender in the Rocket Richard Trophy odds, but has been hampered by nagging injuries and inconsistent play in recent years. Still, a potential move to another team would dramatically alter NHL odds in a variety of markets and create shockwaves throughout one of hockey’s biggest markets.
Auston Matthews Next Team Odds
| Team | Estimated Odds | Implied Probability |
|---|---|---|
| Toronto Maple Leafs | -250 | 73% |
| Columbus Blue Jackets | +150 | 52% |
| San Jose Sharks | +150 | 52% |
| Dallas Stars | +160 | 51% |
| Carolina Hurricanes | +500 | 17% |
| Minnesota Wild | +500 | 17% |
| Anaheim Ducks | +600 | 16% |
| Los Angeles Kings | +650 | 16% |
| Philadelphia Flyers | +800 | 16% |
| Utah Mammoth | +850 | 25% |
$1,500 First Bet OfferClaim bonusPlace your first bet with the token applied. If your first bet loses, you'll get up to $1,500 back in Bonus Bets. Add’l terms apply. Must be 21+ and located in U.S. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. BetMGM Sportsbook available in AZ, CO, DC, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MA, MD, MI, MS, NJ, NY, NC, PA, PR, OH, TN, VA, WV, WY only.
Auston Matthews Next Team Odds Favorites
Toronto Maple Leafs | -250
Despite the noise, the Toronto Maple Leafs are clear favorites in the Auston Matthews next team odds market, with Kalshi trading trends indicating estimated odds of around -250 based on a November 1 payout date. While the market implies strong confidence in Matthews staying put, the longer-term reality is more nuanced.
If a departure ever materializes, it is widely viewed as more plausible near the end of the 2026–27 season rather than in the immediate future. New Maple Leafs GM John Chayka has already made a concerted effort to improve Toronto’s roster, notably acquiring former Tampa Bay Lightning defenseman Darren Radysh in a sign-and-trade. He also hired Jim Hiller, who wasn’t even an early contender in the Maple Leafs next head coach odds, as Toronto’s new bench boss – Hiller coached Matthews early in his Leafs tenure as an assistant to Mike Babcock.
Columbus Blue Jackets | +150
The Columbus Blue Jackets have never been afraid to make a splash for a star American player from a Canadian market, famously luring Johnny Gaudreau away from Calgary in free agency in 2022. That history makes Columbus an intriguing dark horse in the Auston Matthews next team odds market.
The Blue Jackets could eventually pursue another franchise-altering move to convince Zach Werenski, last season’s Norris Trophy odds winner, to remain committed beyond his current deal, which expires after the 2027-28 season – the same summer Matthews can become an unrestricted free agent. Pairing two elite American stars could instantly elevate Columbus into an immediate contender in the Stanley Cup odds.
Alternatively, it’s just as likely the Maple Leafs try and pry Werenski out of Columbus as they have major holes to fill on defense.
San Jose Sharks | +150
The San Jose Sharks are one of the most fascinating long shots in the Auston Matthews next team odds market. Armed with an abundance of young talent, draft picks, and cap flexibility, San Jose would love to add another superstar alongside Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith as the franchise transitions from rebuilding to contending.
The Sharks can offer Matthews both a competitive future and something that may appeal to him personally: relative anonymity in a non-traditional hockey market. That quieter environment reportedly appealed to Mitch Marner when he chose Vegas in free agency in 2025, and it could similarly make San Jose an intriguing destination if Matthews ever decides to leave Toronto.
Auston Matthews Next Team Odds Sleeper Pick
Los Angeles Kings | +650
The Los Angeles Kings make plenty of sense as a potential landing spot in the Auston Matthews next team odds market. With franchise icon Anze Kopitar retiring last season, the Kings could be searching for their next superstar center to keep their championship window open. After hiring Peter Laviolette as head coach, Los Angeles has signaled its intention to remain competitive rather than embark on a rebuild.
The Kings also possess the assets to make a blockbuster deal, potentially building a trade package around Quinton Byfield, who is signed through the 2028-29 season. Matthews’ Southern California roots and the chance to lead another marquee franchise make Los Angeles a compelling fit.
Players Toronto May Target in an Auston Matthews Trade
Michael Misa | San Jose Sharks
David Gonzales-Imagn Images
If the Maple Leafs decide to move Auston Matthews, acquiring Michael Misa from the San Jose Sharks would make plenty of sense. Misa is viewed as a future franchise center with elite offensive upside and would give Toronto a young cornerstone to build around.
San Jose, meanwhile, has already assembled an impressive young core around Macklin Celebrini, including Will Smith and newly drafted Ivar Stenberg. With so much young talent in place, the Sharks could view Matthews as the final piece needed to accelerate their rise into Stanley Cup contention.
Quinton Byfield | Los Angeles Kings
Jayne Kamin-Oncea-Imagn Images
Quinton Byfield is the type of player the Maple Leafs would likely covet in a blockbuster return for Auston Matthews. The former second-overall pick plays a similar style, using his size, skating ability, and two-way game to impact all areas of the ice. Byfield’s calm demeanor and willingness to handle pressure suggest he’d fit well in the Toronto market despite its intense spotlight.
Signed through the 2028-29 season, he would also provide cost certainty and give the Leafs an immediate top-six center capable of growing into a franchise cornerstone.
Tij Iginla | Utah Mammoth
Matt Krohn-Imagn Images
Tij Iginla would be a fascinating target if the Utah Mammoth ever emerged as a serious suitor in the Auston Matthews next team odds. The young franchise has accumulated an impressive collection of prospects and draft assets and may eventually look to make a massive splash to accelerate its rise into contention.
Iginla’s goal-scoring pedigree and star potential would be appealing to Toronto and, with immediate playing time, could be a contender in the Calder Trophy odds. Utah could potentially sweeten an offer by including another premium young piece such as Caleb Desnoyers. If the Leafs ever decide to reset around younger talent, a package built around elite prospects could be difficult to ignore.
- $1,500 First Bet OfferClaim bonus
Place your first bet with the token applied. If your first bet loses, you'll get up to $1,500 back in Bonus Bets. Add’l terms apply. Must be 21+ and located in U.S. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. BetMGM Sportsbook available in AZ, CO, DC, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MA, MD, MI, MS, NJ, NY, NC, PA, PR, OH, TN, VA, WV, WY only.
Best NHL Betting Sites for Auston Matthews Next Team Odds
To make sure you get the most value on your NHL odds, go to the best NHL betting sites prior to placing your wagers throughout the season. You should also check out the best sportsbook promotions as many sportsbooks offer NHL-specific promotions, including as odds boosts, early payouts or profit and parlay boosts.
| Sportsbook bonus | Sportsbook promo code | Sportsbook review |
|---|---|---|
| Stake Promo Code | ODDSMAX | Stake Review |
| bet365 Bonus Code | ODDSPEDIA | bet365 Review |
| Betway Promo Code | N/A | Betway Review |
❓ Auston Matthews Next Team Odds FAQs
What are the current Auston Matthews next team odds?
The Toronto Maple Leafs remain the favourites in the Auston Matthews next team odds market, with several US-based teams, including the Columbus Blue Jackets, San Jose Sharks, and Los Angeles Kings, also drawing interest. These odds are largely speculative and can shift dramatically based on Matthews’ contract status and Toronto’s performance.
Why are the Maple Leafs favoured in the Auston Matthews next team odds?
Toronto is still the most likely destination because Matthews is under contract and the organization remains committed to building a contender around him. New management has already shown an aggressive approach to improving the roster, making a short-term departure appear unlikely.
Which teams could realistically trade for Auston Matthews?
Teams with deep prospect pools and ample draft capital, such as the Sharks, Kings, Ducks, and Mammoth, would be among the most realistic trade partners. Any team acquiring Matthews would likely need to part with multiple premium assets, including top young players and future draft picks.
When could Auston Matthews potentially leave Toronto?
If Matthews ever departs, many around the league believe it is more likely to happen closer to the end of the 2026-27 season rather than in the immediate future. That timeline would give Toronto additional opportunities to contend while also allowing other clubs time to position themselves for a blockbuster pursuit.
Disclaimer: The odds displayed for entertainment, political, and other non-sporting events on this page are purely speculative and intended for entertainment purposes only. These are not real betting markets offered by licensed operators. Please note that the odds above have been generated by Oddspedia for this article only. They are not necessarily reflective of the actual probability of the event occurring and it is not possible to place a wager on this event through Oddspedia. Any implied probabilities derived from these odds are not based on professional bookmaking standards and should not be used for actual wagering decisions. Please gamble responsibly with licensed providers.
Chris Roberts
