Pro Football Hall of Fame: The Best NFL Players Not in the Hall of Fame

© Dale Zanine-USA TODAY Sports
D
Tiago Carvalho
2
Listen
-16:48
  • Facebook Icon
  • X Icon
  • Instagram Icon
  • Telegram Icon

With the NFL preseason well underway, the Oddspedia Insights team started the usual discussion of “Why isn’t <insert player> in the Hall of Fame yet?”

The answer is usually very simple: they aren’t eligible for five years after they played their last NFL game.

“We all have to wait until 2028 for Tom Brady to put on the gold jacket...”

So when are your team’s greatest players going to be eligible to enter the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

I’ve gathered the data for all the most highly rated and successful NFL players who are yet to be inducted, and gathered an AI predictions on who we can expect to join the Pro Football Hall of Fame class.

Best NFL players not in Hall of Fame: potential entry dates

Team Player Eligibility Status
Willie Anderson* Already Eligible
Geno Atkins* 2026
New England PatriotsTampa Bay Buccaneers Tom Brady 2028
Drew Brees* 2026
Dez Bryant 2026
Tennessee Titans Jurrell Casey* 2026
Thomas Davis* 2026
Aaron Donald 2029
New England Patriots Julian Edelman 2026
Jahri Evans* Already Eligible
Arizona Cardinals Larry Fitzgerald* 2026
Antonio Gates Already Eligible
San Francisco 49ers Frank Gore* 2026
New England PatriotsTampa Bay Buccaneers Rob Gronkowski 2027
Todd Gurley 2026
Torry Holt* Already Eligible
Arizona CardinalsSan Francisco 49ers Mike Iupati 2026
Philadelphia Eagles Jason Kelce 2029
Luke Kuechly* Already Eligible
Marshawn Lynch* Already Eligible
Eli Manning* Already Eligible
Philadelphia Eagles LeSean McCoy* 2026
Maurkice Pouncey* 2026
Philip Rivers* 2026
Ben Roethlisberger 2027
Atlanta Falcons Matt Ryan 2029
San Francisco 49ers Alex Smith* 2026
Steve Smith Sr.* Already Eligible
Terrell Suggs* Already Eligible
Fred Taylor* Already Eligible
Adam Vinatieri* Already Eligible
Hines Ward* Already Eligible
Reggie Wayne* Already Eligible
Houston Texans J.J. Watt 2028
Eric Weddle 2027
Jason Witten* 2026
Darren Woodson* Already Eligible
Marshal Yanda* Already Eligible

*shortlisted for the 2026 Pro Football Hall of Fame class

Estimates based on 2025 data 

Pro Football Hall of Fame Candidates: From First Ballot Entries to No Chance at all

First Ballot Locks

Players who should probably be booking flights to Canton, OH.

© Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports
  • Tom Brady – Widely considered the G.O.A.T of the NFL – as sure as a sure thing can be
  • Drew Brees – One of the most statistically prolific QBs in NFL history
  • Aaron Donald – Former NFL Defensive Player of the Year and one of the most dominant defensive players ever – redefined dominant Defensive Tackle play.
  • J.J. Watt – Changed the way 3-front Defensive Ends play the game. Career shortened by injuries from carrying the Texans.
  • Larry Fitzgerald – An all-time great receiver with impeccable stats and former Walter Payton Man of the Year winner
  • Rob Gronkowski – Considered by many to be the greatest tight end of all time, winner of four Super Bowls with the New England Patriots and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

Strong Candidates

They might wait a while, but they should get a gold jacket

© Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports
  • Ben Roethlisberger – The 2004 NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year, two-time Super Bowl-winning quarterback with elite longevity and high level production.
  • Adam Vinatieri – The NFL’s all-time leading scorer with a number of high profile moments across a long career.
  • Luke Kuechly – Elite linebacker whose peak was dominant, despite a shorter career.
  • Reggie Wayne – Consistently great receiver who is a perennial finalist.
  • Terrell Suggs – Former Defensive Player of the Year with a long, impactful career.
  • Marshal Yanda – Dominant offensive guard, consistently one of the best 2 or 3 at his position for over a decade.
  • Jason Kelce – One of the best Centers to ever play in the NFL, a six-time first team All-Pro and one-time Super Bowl winner with the Philadelphia Eagles, turned hit podcaster and broadcaster.

Good Chance

It’s only a matter of time, right?

  • Torry Holt – A statistical powerhouse from the “Greatest Show on Turf” era.
  • Antonio Gates – Revolutionized the tight end position with his receiving skills for the Chargers.
  • Jason Witten – Incredibly durable and productive tight end over a long career.

On the Bubble

If you support their team you probably think they’re a lock…

© Bob Donnan-USA TODAY Sports
  • Steve Smith Sr. – Fiercely competitive receiver and a dynamic returned early in his career, with strong, albeit not top-tier, stats
  • Hines Ward – Known for his toughness, blocking and beaming smile as much as his receiving
  • Eli Manning – Two-time Super Bowl MVP, but with inconsistent regular season stats
  • Frank Gore – The all-time leading rusher not in HOF, his stats may be the product of longevity not excellence
  • Philip Rivers – A top-tier quarterback statistically, but lacked defining playoff success
  • Darren Woodson – Hard-hitting safety from the Cowboys’ 90s dynasty
  • Fred Taylor – Criminally underrated running back with elite per-touch numbers on an unsexy 2000s Jaguars team
  • Jahri Evans – 4x All-Pro and NFL 2010s All-Decade team Guard for the New Orleans Saints
  • Willie Anderson – Elite offensive tackle who will be an automatic finalist for entry in 2026 after finishing just outside the class of 2025

Longshots

These guys can probably book vacations every August

  • Thomas Davis – Inspirational leader and an incredible career with the Carolina Panthers, but his stats may fall short
  • Dez Bryant – Had a dominant, but relatively brief, stretch as a top WR with the Dallas Cowboys
  • Eric Weddle – Very good, versatile safety for a long time with the Chargers, Ravens and Rams.
  • Julian Edelman – Patriots postseason hero and former Super Bowl MVP, lacks regular season volume.
  • Jurrell Casey – Consistently disruptive, 5-time Pro Bowler without the statistical production needed for serious consideration
  • Todd Gurley – Burned very brightly but very briefly for the Los Angeles Rams, peaked with a Offensive POY win.

No chance at all

Great players with great moments we’ll never forget

© Kirby Lee/Image of Sport-USA TODAY Sports
  • Marshawn Lynch – “Beast Mode” was a cultural icon and the de-facto face of the city of Oakland, but he was a throwback in a passing league.
  • Alex Smith – Incredible leader with an incredible comeback after serious injury that eased him to the 2020 NFL Comeback Player of the Year award… but he’ll never make the Hall of Fame.
  • Mike Iupati – Mauling Pro Bowl guard who bullied his way around the NFC West for the Cardinals, 49ers and Seahawks, but not a generational talent.
  • Geno Atkins – Was a disruptive force at DT for the Cincinnati Bengals and an 8-time Pro Bowler, but was the sole bright spot for a bad Cincy team that never achieved greatness.
  • LeSean McCoy – Dynamic, shifty back with impressive volume stats. Picked up two Super Bowl rings at the back end of his career as a bit-part player.
  • Maurkice Pouncey – Considered one of the best centers of his era with character questions. Lacked offseason success that would cap off a quality career.
  • Matt Ryan – One-time NFL MVP Award winner. Consistently a high performing quarterback, but his biggest moment in the media spotlight was leading the Falcons to the Super Bowl where they gave up a 28-3 lead to the Patriots.

The 2026 Pro Football Hall of Fame Shortlist

Quarterbacks (3 Semi-Finalists)

New Orleans Saints Drew Brees New York Giants Eli Manning
Los Angeles Chargers Philip Rivers

Running Backs (2 Semi-Finalists)

San Francisco 49ers Frank Gore Jacksonville Jaguars Fred Taylor

Wide Receivers (5 Semi-Finalists)

Arizona Cardinals Larry Fitzgerald Los Angeles Rams Torry Holt
Carolina Panthers Steve Smith Sr. Pittsburgh Steelers Hines Ward
Indianapolis Colts Reggie Wayne

Tight Ends (1 Semi-Finalist)

Dallas Cowboys Jason Witten

Offensive Linemen (6 Semi-Finalists)

Cincinnati Bengals Willie Anderson (T) Detroit Lions Lomas Brown (T)
New Orleans Saints Jahri Evans (G) Miami Dolphins Richmond Webb (T)
Las Vegas Raiders Steve Wisniewski (G) Baltimore Ravens Marshal Yanda (G)

Defensive Linemen (3 Semi-Finalists)

Indianapolis Colts Robert Mathis (DE) New England Patriots Vince Wilfork (DT/NT)
Minnesota Vikings Kevin Williams (DT)

Linebackers (2 Semi-Finalists)

Carolina Panthers Luke Kuechly Baltimore Ravens Terrell Suggs

Defensive Backs (3 Semi-Finalists)

New England Patriots Rodney Harrison (S) Seattle Seahawks Earl Thomas (S)
Dallas Cowboys Darren Woodson (S)

Punters/Kickers (1 Semi-Finalist)

New England Patriots Adam Vinatieri (K)

Pro Football Hall of Fame FAQs

How does the Pro Football Hall of Fame’s Selection Process work?

The Pro Football Hall of Fame selection process begins with a large list of nominees, which is then narrowed down to 25 semifinalists and then 15 finalists. These finalists are rigorously discussed by the Selection Committee, who vote on them, requiring an 80% affirmative vote for induction. Between four and eight new members are typically selected each year, ensuring a high standard of excellence.

Who Selects New Hall of Fame Members?

A 50-person Selection Committee, primarily composed of media representatives from each NFL city and at-large delegates, selects new Hall of Fame members. This committee meets annually before the Super Bowl to discuss candidates and cast their votes. There are also specialized committees for Seniors, Coaches, and Contributors to ensure broader consideration.

What’s the difference between a Modern-Era Player Nominee, Semifinalist, and Finalist?

A nominee is any eligible player proposed for consideration, forming a large initial pool. That pool is then reduced to 25 semifinalists, representing the top contenders. Finally, the list is cut to 15 finalists, who undergo the most intense scrutiny and are ultimately voted on for induction by the selection committee.

Which current NFL players will make the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Predicting future Hall of Famers is always speculative, but several current NFL players are building strong cases. Quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes and Aaron Rodgers, along with star offensive players like Travis Kelce, Tyreek Hill, and Mike Evans, are often cited as strong candidates. Elite defensive players such as Aaron Donald and Myles Garrett also appear to be on a clear path to Canton.

When will Drew Brees enter the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Drew Brees will be eligible for Hall of Fame induction with the Class of 2026. The former Saints quarterback retired as one of the most prolific passers in NFL history, holding numerous records and a Super Bowl XLIV MVP trophy. He is widely expected to be a first-ballot inductee, celebrating a career defined by remarkable accuracy, leadership, and statistical dominance.

Why is the Pro Football Hall of Fame in Canton, Ohio?

The Pro Football Hall of Fame is in Canton, Ohio for three main historical reasons. The American Professional Football Association, which became the NFL, was founded there in 1920. Canton was also home to the early dominant Canton Bulldogs, who the legendary Jim Thorpe played for. Canton citizens launched a highly organized campaign in the 1960s to secure the Hall’s location there.

When will Tom Brady go into the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Tom Brady becomes eligible for the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2028, following his retirement after the 2022 season. As a seven-time Super Bowl champion and three-time NFL MVP, he is universally considered the greatest quarterback of all time. His induction is a mere formality, with experts viewing him as the most certain first-ballot lock in the history of the sport.

Is the Pro Football Hall of Fame worth the trip?

For passionate football fans, the Pro Football Hall of Fame is absolutely worth the trip, offering a deep dive into the sport’s history and its greatest legends. Beyond the iconic Hall of Fame gallery with its bronze busts, the museum features interactive exhibits, historical displays, and artifacts from all eras of the game. Many visitors praise the immersive experiences and the chance to connect with football’s rich heritage.

From personal experience: the Pro Football Hall of Fame is one of the best tourist attractions in the Eastern United States and outranks the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame just up the highway in Cleveland, OH.

Will Aaron Donald be a first ballot entry to the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Aaron Donald is eligible for the Hall of Fame Class of 2029 after his dominant career with the Los Angeles Rams. As a three-time Defensive Player of the Year and one-time Super Bowl winner, he is considered one of the most disruptive interior linemen to ever play the game. There is a strong consensus among analysts that Donald is an undisputed first-ballot lock, with many expecting a near-unanimous selection.

When will J.J. Watt be Pro Football Hall of Fame eligible?

Eligible for the Class of 2028, J.J. Watt is viewed as a generational talent who redefined the defensive end position. The three-time Defensive Player of the Year built a legacy of relentless disruption and game-changing plays for the Houston Texans. His peak performance and league-wide impact make him a consensus choice to enter the Hall of Fame on his first attempt.

When is Larry Fitzgerald eligible for the Hall of Fame?

Larry Fitzgerald will be eligible for Hall of Fame consideration for the Class of 2026. The longtime Arizona Cardinal is second all-time in career receiving yards and receptions, showcasing remarkable consistency and arguably the best hands in NFL history. His on-field production and esteemed reputation as a Walter Payton Man of the Year make him a very likely first-ballot inductee.

How strong is the case for Rob Gronkowski to enter the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Rob Gronkowski becomes eligible for the Hall of Fame in 2027, following a career where he established himself as the most dominant tight end of his era. His unique combination of size, speed, and blocking ability resulted in four Super Bowl rings and numerous records. He is considered a near-certain first-ballot selection, having completely revolutionized the tight end position.

Want NFL Betting Insights?

What does Oddspedia do?

We’re here to help you find the best value in Canadian sports betting. Our platform compares top-rated sites and brings you the most rewarding betting offers available. To help you choose wisely, we provide detailed promo reviews that explain everything before you sign up. We are your source for top codes, whether it’s a bet365 bonus code, or the latest BC Game bonus code. Our insights and odds comparisons help you pick the right bookmaker and maximize your returns.

Don't forget to share with friends
  • Facebook Icon
  • X Icon
  • Instagram Icon
  • Telegram Icon
    )    (       (       (      (            (       (
 ( /(    )\ )    )\ )    )\ )   )\ )         )\ )    )\ )     (
 )\())  (()/(   (()/(   (()/(  (()/(   (    (()/(   (()/(     )\
((_)\    /(_))   /(_))   /(_))  /(_))  )\    /(_))   /(_)) ((((_)(
  ((_)  (_))_   (_))_   (_))   (_))   ((_)  (_))_   (_))    )\ _ )\
 / _ \   |   \   |   \  / __|  | _ \  | __|  |   \  |_ _|   (_)_\(_)
| (_) |  | |) |  | |) | \__ \  |  _/  | _|   | |) |  | |     / _ \
 \___/   |___/   |___/  |___/  |_|    |___|  |___/  |___|   /_/ \_\