NFL Study: What If The Tush Push Gets Banned?

© IMAGO / Icon Sportswire
URUBU
JoaoPedro1999
Tiago Carvalho
3
Listen
-19:05
  • Facebook Icon
  • X Icon
  • Instagram Icon
  • Telegram Icon

It got a stay of execution at the NFL League Meeting, but the most controversial play in the NFL has remained a massive talking point through the first half of the NFL season.

With false starts and offsides being missed, teams finding new ways to defend it, new offensive wrinkles from the Eagles to capitalise on the focus opponents put on the play… The Tush Push is guaranteed a mention on ESPN Sports Center every Monday morning.

The Tush Push, a short-yardage tactic perfected by the Philadelphia Eagles, has redefined offensive efficiency and drove the team to a Super Bowl victory in February.

“…every team in the league is allowed to run it. One team runs it incredibly well, nobody seems to be able to stop it,”

With the NFL Owners meeting over the next two days to discuss making the play illegal, amongst other topics, a potential ban sparks a fascinating “what if” scenario.

We’ll examine how the Eagles’ dominance, built on an 84.9% success rate, might crumble and how other teams, like the Washington Commanders, could have seen drastically different seasons.

Through data-driven analysis, we’ll explore the play’s impact on game outcomes, playoff seeding, and team records. We’ll also delve into the debate surrounding its safety and the NFL’s rule-changing process, uncovering the true influence of this game-changing play.

Key Findings

  • Eagles Win/Loss record in the 2024 regular season was 14-3. Without the Tush Push play it could have been 11-4-2
  • Without the Tush Push, the Eagles could have seen their playoff seeding drop from the 2-seed as winners of the NFC East down to the 6-seed as an NFC wildcard
  • In total the Tush Push contributed in 15 touchdown drives and 4 field goals to the Eagles season*
  • At least 11 other NFL teams have tried to run the Tush Push play at some point since 2022 with a success rate of 48.9%.
  • The Washington Commanders could have won NFC East and taken the 2-Seed without the Tush Push.
  • Tush Push Success Compared to other Short Yardage Plays – The play succeeded for the Eagles at 82% in 2024 – other short yardage plays (3rd or 4th and 1-2 yards) succeed at between 55 and 75%.
  • The play has been called dangerous on numerous occasions by NFL commentators and NFL team staff, however the injury rate for the play according to NFL league data is 0%.

* based on the Tush Push being used during a scoring drive or as the scoring play

What if the Tush Push was banned?

Imagine the NFL without the Tush Push. A play that redefined short-yardage conversions and carried the Philadelphia Eagles to Super Bowl victory.

Ahead of the NFL owners meeting, let’s look at the hypothetical ban of this controversial play, focusing on its impact on the Philadelphia Eagles and the wider league.

We’ll explore whether the Eagles’ Super Bowl victory would still have materialized, dissecting the play’s 84.9% success rate against standard NFL short yardage plays.

By examining potential shifts in game outcomes and team standings, we’ll reveal how other NFL teams may have had very different seasons.

Through data-driven insights and statistical breakdowns, we’ll uncover the true influence of this game-changing play.

Would the Eagles still have won the Super Bowl without the Tush Push?

© Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

In short? Probably not.

At the start of the playoffs, the 2-seed Eagles were +700 in the odds to win the Super Bowl, with an implied probability of 12.5% (odds provided by BetMGM).

If they hadn’t used the Tush Push play, which contributed to drives ending in 15 touchdowns and four field goals throughout the regular season, their record could have been 11-4-2 which would lead to them finishing as the six-seed in the NFC.

So let’s compare their odds of winning the Super Bowl to the 6-seed Washington Commanders, who were priced at +3500, with an implied probability of 2.8%.

Philadelphia would likely have entered every game of the NFL playoffs as underdogs in matchups with very tough opponents: the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, who had already beaten the Eagles earlier in the year, the all-conquering Detroit Lions and then, if all went to script: another game with the Washington Commanders.

Just how important was the Tush Push to the Eagles’ Super Bowl victory?

The Philadelphia Eagles were one of the best teams in the NFL throughout the 2024 season. They proved that through the regular with seven games against teams that would ultimately go on to make the playoffs.

The Tush Push was used 50 times across the regular season and playoffs – on 41 of those instances it was successful, for a success percentage of 82.0%.

Since they first used the play in 2022, the Eagles have succeeded on 101 of 119 Tush Push plays for an 84.9% success rate.

If they couldn’t use that play the success rate on those particular plays, they would use an alternative play more in-keeping with standard NFL offenses. NFL offenses convert 3rd and 4th down plays 39.8% and 56.6% of the time.

While data on short yardage conversions in the NFL is hard to pinpoint: across the FBS in college football, offenses generally convert between 70-75% on 3rd or 4th-and-1 and between 55-60% on 3rd or 4th-and-2 attempts.

Given that Saquon Barkley joined the Eagles at the start of the 2024 season, and subsequently had a record setting season as the best running back in the NFL, it’s fair to surmise that the Eagles would likely still converted in many of the situations where they ran successful Tush Push plays.

But the percentages for success are lower. They could have lost close games where they won by less than the scores gained using the play.

Would they still have been a good team without the Tush Push? Yes. They’d still have made the playoffs.

They could still have won the Super Bowl, but with an implied probability of 2.8%: they’d need to win road games against good NFC teams and would need to beat the Washington Commanders, who they potentially would have lost to twice in the regular season without the Tush Push.

How would it have affected other teams’ records?

There are three games in the Philadelphia Eagles Super Bowl winning season that could have had different outcomes if the birds were banned from using their favorite play.

  • Week 6 – Eagles vs Browns – Win 20-16
  • Week 11 – Commanders vs Eagles – Win 18-26
  • Week 13 – Eagles vs Ravens – Win 24-19

Without the Tush Push, those three wins turn into one loss and two ties.

  • Week 6 – Eagles vs Browns – Tie 16-16
  • Week 11 – Commanders vs Eagles – Loss 18-16
  • Week 13 – Eagles vs Ravens – Tie 19-19
It would be easy to say the Washington Commanders are the team who have the most to gain if the Tush Push was banned by the NFL.

Those different results change the three teams records accordingly:

Wins Losses Ties Result
Cleveland Browns 3 14 0 Missed Playoffs
Cleveland Browns 3 13 1 Missed Playoffs
Wins Losses Ties Result
Baltimore Ravens (3) 12 5 0 AFC North Champion (3)
Baltimore Ravens (2) 12 4 1 AFC North Champion (3)*
Wins Losses Ties Result
Washington Commanders (6) 12 5 0 6-Seed Wildcard
Washington Commanders (2) 13 4 0 NFC East Champion (2)

* Had the Ravens won the tied game with the Eagles, they would have taken the AFC 2-seed

The Cleveland Browns saw no real change in fortunes from the alternative outcome of their game with the Eagles.

The Baltimore Ravens would still have won the AFC North. Their game with the Eagles could have ended as a tie, but with a Ravens win: they’d finish the season with the same record as the Bills and would take the 2-seed AFC by way of winning their in-season matchup, 35-10.

Had all other results gone the same way: they could have faced one another in the AFC Divisional round with Baltimore having homefield advantage.

That game ended with Buffalo winning, but could the Ravens have sealed a spot in the AFC Conference Championship game at M&T Bank Stadium?

The biggest winner of the Tush Push had the play been banned ahead of the 2024 season would have been the Washington Commanders.

Without the play the Commanders could have won another game against the Philadelphia Eagles for a clean sweep of their in-division rivals.

That win and the Eagles dropping games elsewhere would secure the Commanders an incredible NFC East title and the 2-seed in the NFC playoff standings.

That, added to the debacle of the Eagles running the Tush Push six times in a row on the Commanders’ goal line only to be awarded four defensive penalties and a threat of the referees awarding a touchdown to the Eagles.

How does the Tush Push Work? Why is it so effective?

The Tush Push explained

The Tush Push, popularized by the Philadelphia Eagles, is a modified quarterback sneak play used in short yardage situations.

The play gets its nickname because one or more players push the quarterback forwards after the snap. Aiding the runner in this way is allowed within NFL rules and happens on almost every rushing play.

The point that marks out the Tush Push from other rushing plays, and has led to other teams questioning its legality, is that aiding the runner is a designed part of the play and key to its success.

Why do we keep hearing about Jalen Hurts squatting 600lbs? Why does that matter?

Jalen Hurts is a pretty unique athlete at the quarterback position in that he’s incredibly strong as well as being a student of the mental side of the position.

The success of the Tush Push is often attributed to his unique traits and strength and it is true: the Eagles probably wouldn’t run the play quite so much without him at quarterback.

However… he’s not the only quarterback who has successfully run the Tush Push for the Eagles during the 2024 season.

Second and third string quarterbacks, and notably less athletic Kenny Pickett and Tanner McKee both ran the play and succeeded during the last three games of the regular season when Jalen Hurts was injured.

Why does it work so well for the Eagles?

The little secret to the Eagles success on the Tush Push isn’t that little.

Every Tush Push play involves the quarterback sneaking behind the left side of the Eagles offensive line. Left guard, Landon Dickerson and left tackle, Jordan Mailata are among the best in the league at their positions: 8th and 1st in the Pro Football Focus rankings at their positions respectively.

They both stand over 6’6 tall and weigh just under 700 lbs combined.

The Eagles offensive line as a unit is one of the best in football: both tackles rank in the top five of the PFF rankings for 2024, three of the five starters made the NFL Pro Bowl and three were named All-Pro for the season.

The combination of excellent offensive line play, one of the league’s best positional coaches in OL coach, Jeff Stoutland, a dedication to making practicing the play until its perfect and, yes, an athletic quarterback who can squat 600lbs means the Tush Push is an enviable weapon for the Philadelphia Eagles, even if football luminaries don’t like it.

Long-time NFL broadcaster, Jim Nantz was emphatic in his dislike for the play.

“I’m done with the Tush Push, I think it needs to go away. I know that’s a big part of the arsenal for the Eagles. I think it needs to change. Now, they execute it better than anyone, so Philadelphia fans will be in outcry, saying, ‘Why are you penalizing us? ‘ I don’t like the play. I just don’t like the play. It feels automatic.”.

Does anyone else run the Tush Push?

Since 2022, 11 other teams have attempted to run a variant of the Tush Push play, including the New York Giants, New England Patriots, Chicago Bears, Jacksonville Jaguars, and Kansas City Chiefs.

The Green Bay Packers, who filed the proposal with the NFL to have the play banned, have run the play before too.

The available data would indicate other teams attempting the Tush Push succeeded at a rate of 48.9%.

As NFL insider Adam Schefter put it: “…every team in the league is allowed to run it. One team runs it incredibly well, nobody seems to be able to stop it.”

Is the Tush Push fair?

The Tush Push has been debated since it first appeared in the league in 2022: it utilises a part of football that happens on nearly every single running play – offensive players pushing the ball-carrier forward for extra yards.

This is not a scripted part of most plays where it occurs – it gets described as ‘second effort’ by commentators and can often lead to first downs or touchdowns.

The Philadelphia Eagles were the first team to make it a part of their regular offense: using it on 3rd-and-1 or 4th-and-short 50 times through the 2024 season.

Since its introduction the Eagles have run the play 119 times, succeeding on 84.9% of attempts.

Some commentators have complained about the lack of safety on the play and there have been calls for it to be banned on safety grounds.

Is the Tush Push actually a dangerous play? The injury data

As posted on Twitter in February 2025: CBS NFL insider, Jonathan Jones confirmed the injury rate for the Tush Push play according to official NFL league data is 0%.

It’s actually a safe play. As safe as plays on an NFL field can be, so it seems.

There is a lot of discussion over the potential injuries the play could cause. Buffalo Bills head coach, Sean McDermott was recently quoted on his concerns with the play:

”To me, there’s always been an injury risk with that play, and I’ve expressed that opinion for the last couple of years or so when it really started to come into play the way it’s being used…”

McDermott’s Bills ran a variant of the Tush Push play during the 2025 AFC Conference championship game – they succeeded 0 times on 4 attempts according to Sports Illustrated.

Troy Vincent, NFL Executive Vice President of Football Operations, expressed his feelings on the play too: “…Hey, the Philadelphia Eagles, they just do it better than everybody else. But there are some concerns.”

Former Philadelphia Eagles center turned NFL analyst and podcaster, Jason Kelce gave his thoughts on the play to NBC’s Devin McCourty in October:

“…All the weight and everything lying up on top of you… And you’ve got to wait for everybody else to get up before you can get up. It’s a grueling play, for sure. And, you know, if you do it right, you’re at the bottom of the pile. If you’re not at the bottom, it usually didn’t go well.”.

How does the NFL change rules?

The NFL’s rule change process is a structured procedure that involves proposals, discussions, and ultimately, a vote by team owners. Here’s a breakdown of the key steps:

1. Proposal Submission:

  • NFL teams can submit proposals for changes to playing rules, bylaws, and resolutions.
  • The NFL’s Competition Committee also plays a significant role in proposing rule changes. This committee is comprised of coaches, general managers, and team executives.

2. Competition Committee Review:

  • The Competition Committee thoroughly examines the proposed rule changes.
  • They consider various factors, including player safety, the impact on the game’s integrity, and potential officiating challenges.
  • The committee then makes recommendations to the NFL owners.

3. League Meetings:

  • The proposed rule changes are presented and discussed at the NFL’s annual league meetings, held annually at the end of March in Florida.
  • These meetings provide a forum for team owners, coaches, and league officials to debate the merits of each proposal.

4. Owner Vote:

  • NFL rule changes require a vote of approval from at least 24 of the 32 team owners (a 75% majority) to be adopted.
  • This voting process ensures that any rule changes have broad support from the league’s stakeholders.

5. Implementation:

  • If a rule change is approved, the NFL works to implement it for the upcoming season.
  • This involves educating players, coaches, and officials on the new rules and ensuring consistent application.

Key considerations in this process:

  • Player Safety: A primary focus of the NFL’s rule change process is to enhance player safety.
  • Game Integrity: The league also strives to maintain the integrity and competitive balance of the game.
  • Officiating: Rule changes must be clear and enforceable by NFL officials.

Methodology

This analysis utilized a mixed-methods approach.

Quantitative data was collected from the 2024 NFL season, focusing on the Philadelphia Eagles’ “Tush Push” play. Success rates were calculated based on first downs, touchdowns, positive yardage, or accepted defensive penalties.

Comparative statistics were gathered for other NFL teams’ attempts and standard short-yardage plays. Simulated scenarios were constructed to evaluate the impact of a potential ban, adjusting team records and playoff seeding.

Quotes were gathered from NFL commentator statements, player quotes, and expert opinions on the play’s safety and effectiveness.

Want NFL betting insights?

Don't forget to share with friends
  • Facebook Icon
  • X Icon
  • Instagram Icon
  • Telegram Icon
    )    (       (       (      (            (       (
 ( /(    )\ )    )\ )    )\ )   )\ )         )\ )    )\ )     (
 )\())  (()/(   (()/(   (()/(  (()/(   (    (()/(   (()/(     )\
((_)\    /(_))   /(_))   /(_))  /(_))  )\    /(_))   /(_)) ((((_)(
  ((_)  (_))_   (_))_   (_))   (_))   ((_)  (_))_   (_))    )\ _ )\
 / _ \   |   \   |   \  / __|  | _ \  | __|  |   \  |_ _|   (_)_\(_)
| (_) |  | |) |  | |) | \__ \  |  _/  | _|   | |) |  | |     / _ \
 \___/   |___/   |___/  |___/  |_|    |___|  |___/  |___|   /_/ \_\