MLB Comeback Player of the Year Odds: Michael Harris II the New Favorite in the NL

© Dale Zanine-Imagn Images
Hinni
Jan Veit
2
Listen
-11:11
  • Facebook Icon
  • X Icon
  • Instagram Icon
  • Telegram Icon

The MLB Comeback Player of the Year odds market is all about redemption, resilience and opportunity.

This award rewards players who rebound from significant injuries, down years or career-threatening setbacks to make a meaningful impact over a full 162-game season.

The Comeback Player of the Year betting odds offer a compelling mix of proven stars and high-upside longshots worth tracking throughout the season...

Context matters in this market just as much as raw talent. Playing time, health history and team role can swing this market rapidly.

Like the MVP odds or Cy Young odds, the Comeback Player of the Year market offers a flurry of interesting picks to be made. Head on over to our best sportsbooks delivering the top MLB odds prior to placing your MLB picks.

⚾ 2026 AL Comeback Player of the Year odds

Player Odds Implied Probability
Yordan Alvarez -15000 99.34%
Los Angeles Angels Mike Trout +10000 0.99%

⚾ 2026 NL Comeback Player of the Year odds

Player Odds Implied Probability
Michael Harris II +140 41.67%
 Sandy Alcantara +225 30.77%
Los Angeles Dodgers Tanner Scott +700 12.50%
  • Bet $10 Get $200 in Bonus Bets Win or Lose
    Claim bonus

    Minimum $10 deposit required. Minimum odds -500 or greater. Bonus Bets wager excluded from returns. New customers only. T&CS, time limits and exclusions apply. Bets restrictions and T&C's apply. GAMBLING PROBLEM? CALL 1-800-GAMBLER (AZ, CO, IN, KY, LA, MD, NC, NJ, OH, VA) or 1-800-BETS OFF (IA). 21+ only(18+ in KY). Must be present in AZ/CO/IA/IN/KY/LA (select parishes)/NC/NJ/OH/VA.

AL Comeback Player of the Year odds: Favorites

Yordan Alvarez | -15000 odds to win MLB Comeback Player of the Year

Troy Taormina-Imagn Images

We’re running out of words to describe the season Houston Astros slugger Yordan Alvarez is having. The favorite in the AL Comeback Player of the Year odds is also a leading contender in the AL MVP odds after only playing in 48 games last season.

Few players can change games at the plate like a healthy Alvarez. He offers elite power, plate discipline and big game pedigree. Through 152 games, he was third in the AL in hits (170), while also among the league leaders in RBI (99), walks (105), and home runs (40), making him a good bet in the MLB home run odds leader market and a potential Triple Crown winner. 

No player has won the Triple Crown since Miguel Cabrera in 2012.

Mike Trout | +10000 odds to win MLB Comeback Player of the year

Mike Trout remains a longshot in the MLB Comeback Player of the Year odds, but his 2026 season has provided plenty of evidence that the veteran slugger is back to being a dangerous offensive force. Through Sept. 21, Trout is hitting .241 with 21 home runs, 53 RBI, and an .800 OPS across 494 at-bats.

Trout’s power has been particularly encouraging after several injury-plagued seasons. He hit his 21st homer on Sept. 11 against Washington, snapping a 27-game home run drought and moving into 54th place on MLB’s all-time home run list.

At 35, a return to consistent everyday production gives Trout a compelling comeback narrative. His current numbers are not at the level of his MVP-caliber seasons, but staying healthy and producing 20-plus home runs after his recent injury struggles keeps him relevant as a longshot in the MLB Comeback Player of the Year odds.

Looking to bet on the MLB Comeback Player of the Year odds? Check out Oddspedia’s bet calculator and odds calculator!

NL Comeback Player of the Year odds: Favorite

Michael Harris II | +140 odds to win MLB Comeback Player of the Year

Michael Harris II has put together a strong rebound season, making him a notable candidate in the MLB Comeback Player of the Year odds after a disappointing 2025 campaign. Through 151 games, Harris is hitting .289 with 26 home runs, 85 RBI, 11 stolen bases and an .804 OPS, providing consistent production near the top of Atlanta’s lineup.

Harris’ offensive turnaround has been particularly impressive after his OPS fell to .678 last season. He has also delivered several big performances down the stretch, including a 4-for-5 game with a three-run homer against Philadelphia on Sept. 12 that gave him his 25th home run of the season.

His production has helped Atlanta maintain a strong position in the NL East, with the Braves sitting at 92-64 as of Sept. 21. Harris’ return to impact form has made him an important piece of Atlanta’s postseason push and keeps the Braves relevant in the World Series odds.

NL Comeback Player of the Year odds: Sleeper pick

Miami Marlins Sandy Alcantara | +225 odds to win MLB Comeback Player of the Year

Sandy Alcantara remains one of the leading candidates in the NL Comeback Player of the Year odds after returning from a difficult two-year stretch. He missed the entire 2024 season while recovering from Tommy John surgery before posting a 5.36 ERA across 31 starts in 2025. This season, the former NL Cy Young winner has returned to being one of the National League’s most durable starters.

Alcantara has made 33 starts and leads the NL with 212 innings pitched, while recording 152 strikeouts and a 3.91 ERA. His 3.0 WAR also represents a significant improvement over last season, although he has struggled recently, going 0-4 with a 7.57 ERA and 1.57 WHIP over his last five starts.

The combination of returning from major surgery, handling a full starter’s workload and producing substantially better results than in 2025 gives Alcantara a strong comeback narrative. His durability and overall improvement keep him firmly in the conversation as the season enters its final weeks.

  • $1,500 First Bet Offer
    Claim bonus

    Place your first bet with the token applied. If your first bet loses, you'll get up to $1,500 back in Bonus Bets. Add’l terms apply. Must be 21+ and located in U.S. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. BetMGM Sportsbook available in AZ, CO, DC, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MA, MD, MI, MS, NJ, NY, NC, PA, PR, OH, TN, VA, WV, WY only.

🏆 AL Comeback Player of the Year odds: Betting history

Year Player Team Position
2025 Jacob deGrom Texas Rangers P
2024 Garrett Crochet Chi White Sox P
2023 Liam Hendriks Chi White Sox P
2022 Justin Verlander Houston P
2021 Trey Mancini Baltimore 1B/OF
2020 Salvador Perez Kansas City C
2019 Carlos Carrasco Cleveland P
2018 David Price Boston SP
2017 Mike Moustakas Kansas City 3B
2016 Rick Porcello Boston SP
2015 Prince Fielder Texas 1B
2014 Chris Young Seattle P

🏆 NL Comeback Player of the Year odds: Betting history

Year Player Team Position
2025 Ronald Acuna Jr. Atlanta OF
2024 Chris Sale Atlanta P
2023 Cody Bellinger Chi Cubs OF/1B
2022 Albert Pujols St. Louis DH
2021 Buster Posey San Francisco C
2020 Daniel Bard Colorado P
2019 Josh Donaldson Atlanta 3B
2018 Jonny Venters Atlanta RP
2017 Greg Holland Colorado P
2016 Anthony Rendon Washington 3B
2015 Matt Harvey NY Mets P
2014 Casey McGehee Miami 3B

Our best MLB betting sites

To make sure you get the most value on your MLB odds, go to the best MLB betting sites prior to placing your wagers throughout the regular season.

Sportsbook bonus Sportsbook promo code Sportsbook review
Stake Promo Code ODDSMAX Stake Review
bet365 Bonus Code ODDSPEDIA bet365 Review
Betway Promo Code N/A Betway Review

Looking for MLB insights?

If you’re looking for expert insight on the MLB, take a look at some of our other articles:

  • $1,500 First Bet Offer
    Claim bonus

    Place your first bet with the token applied. If your first bet loses, you'll get up to $1,500 back in Bonus Bets. Add’l terms apply. Must be 21+ and located in U.S. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. BetMGM Sportsbook available in AZ, CO, DC, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MA, MD, MI, MS, NJ, NY, NC, PA, PR, OH, TN, VA, WV, WY only.

❓ MLB Comeback Player of the Year FAQs

Who is the favorite on the Comeback Player of the Year odds board?

The favorites for MLB Comeback Player of the Year in both the National League (NL) and American League (AL) are typically players returning from injuries, poor performance, or extended absences. Sandy Alcantara is the favorite in the NL while Yordan Alvarez is the favorite in the AL.

How is the MLB Comeback Player of the Year determined

The MLB Comeback Player of the Year award is determined by MLB.com writers and analysts, who vote at the end of the season. The award is given to one player in each league (AL and NL) who has made a significant comeback, whether from injury, personal struggles, or a major dip in performance.

Unlike awards like MVP or Cy Young, this honor is less about statistical dominance and more about resilience, perseverance, and impact on a team’s success. Factors such as OPS, ERA, WAR, and overall team performance can influence voting, but the story behind the comeback plays a huge role.

Who won Comeback Player of the Year in 2025?

In 2025, the MLB Comeback Player of the Year winners were Jacob deGrom (Texas Rangers, AL) and Ronald Acuna Jr. (Atlanta Braves, NL). Their comebacks were recognized not only by their statistics but also by their impact on their teams’ success, making them deserving winners of the award.

Disclaimer: The odds displayed for entertainment, political, and other non-sporting events on this page are purely speculative and intended for entertainment purposes only. These are not real betting markets offered by licensed operators. Please note that the odds above have been generated by Oddspedia for this article only. They are not necessarily reflective of the actual probability of the event occurring and it is not possible to place a wager on this event through Oddspedia. Any implied probabilities derived from these odds are not based on professional bookmaking standards and should not be used for actual wagering decisions. Please gamble responsibly with licensed providers.

Don't forget to share with friends
  • Facebook Icon
  • X Icon
  • Instagram Icon
  • Telegram Icon
    )    (       (       (      (            (       (
 ( /(    )\ )    )\ )    )\ )   )\ )         )\ )    )\ )     (
 )\())  (()/(   (()/(   (()/(  (()/(   (    (()/(   (()/(     )\
((_)\    /(_))   /(_))   /(_))  /(_))  )\    /(_))   /(_)) ((((_)(
  ((_)  (_))_   (_))_   (_))   (_))   ((_)  (_))_   (_))    )\ _ )\
 / _ \   |   \   |   \  / __|  | _ \  | __|  |   \  |_ _|   (_)_\(_)
| (_) |  | |) |  | |) | \__ \  |  _/  | _|   | |) |  | |     / _ \
 \___/   |___/   |___/  |___/  |_|    |___|  |___/  |___|   /_/ \_\