NFL Comeback Player of the Year Odds: Can Mahomes Win Comeback Player and MVP?

Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images
Jan Veit
a
Tiago Carvalho
3
Listen
-16:35
  • Facebook Icon
  • X Icon
  • Instagram Icon
  • Telegram Icon

The race for NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds is always one of the most intriguing NFL futures markets, rewarding players who overcome adversity to return to elite form. This year’s field is packed with star power, led by Patrick Mahomes after an uncharacteristically difficult campaign by his lofty standards.

Close behind among NFL picks are talented challengers such as Malik Nabers and Kyler Murray, both of whom have compelling cases to put together bounce-back seasons.

12 of the last 17 NFL Comeback players of the Year have been quarterbacks...

Whether returning from injury or looking to rebound after a disappointing year, each contender brings a unique path to the award. Below, we break down the latest NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds, analyze the favorites, and identify the best value bets ahead of the 2026 NFL schedule.

🏈 2026-27 NFL Comeback Player of the Year Odds

Player Odds Implied Probability
Patrick Mahomes -260 72.22%
Kyler Murray +1500 6.25%
Michael Penix Jr. +1800 5.26%
Joe Burrow +1800 5.26%
Kirk Cousins +1800 5.26%
Fred Warner +2000 4.76%
Aaron Donald +2200 4.35%
Brock Bowers +2500 3.85%
George Kittle +2500 3.85%
Daniel Jones +2800 3.45%

Odds provided by bet365 – accurate as of October 1

  • Bet $10 Get $200 in Bonus Bets Win or Lose
    Claim bonus

    Minimum $10 deposit required. Minimum odds -500 or greater. Bonus Bets wager excluded from returns. New customers only. T&CS, time limits and exclusions apply. Bets restrictions and T&C's apply. GAMBLING PROBLEM? CALL 1-800-GAMBLER (AZ, CO, IN, KY, LA, MD, NC, NJ, OH, VA) or 1-800-BETS OFF (IA). 21+ only(18+ in KY). Must be present in AZ/CO/IA/IN/KY/LA (select parishes)/NC/NJ/OH/VA.

NFL Comeback Player of the Year Odds Favorites

Patrick Mahomes | -260 odds to win NFL Comeback Player of the Year

Denny Medley-Imagn Images

Patrick Mahomes headlines the NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds after returning from a torn ACL/LCL and helping Kansas City open the 2026 season 3-0. Mahomes has completed 67 of 98 passes for 812 yards, seven touchdowns and two interceptions through three games, including a 246-yard, two-touchdown performance in a 24-10 win over Miami in Week 3.

Mahomes’ strong start has also put him firmly in contention in the NFL MVP odds. He entered the season looking to rebound from career lows across several major passing categories in 2025, and his early production has quickly put the two-time MVP back into the conversation. NFL.com identified him as a leading Comeback Player of the Year candidate before the season, while his MVP case has strengthened with Kansas City’s unbeaten start.

If Mahomes were to win both awards, it would be unprecedented. No player has ever won the AP NFL MVP and AP Comeback Player of the Year in the same season. Christian McCaffrey came closest in 2025, becoming the first player to be named a finalist for MVP, Offensive Player of the Year and Comeback Player of the Year in the same season.

Kyler Murray | +1500 odds to win NFL Comeback Player of the Year

Jeffrey Becker-Imagn Images

Kyler Murray remains in the NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds conversation after returning from a concussion in Week 3. Murray missed Minnesota’s Week 2 game after suffering the injury in the season opener, then returned to start against Tampa Bay. He completed 15 of 29 passes for 168 yards, one touchdown and one interception while adding 17 rushing yards in the Vikings’ 23-16 win.

While the numbers were modest, Murray has a major weapon in Justin Jefferson, who entered Week 3 with 147 receiving yards and two touchdowns before finishing the game with 32 yards. Jefferson has 179 yards and two scores through three weeks and is also a candidate in NFL Offensive Player of the Year odds. A productive connection with Jefferson could help Murray strengthen his case as the season progresses.

Michael Penix Jr. | +1800 odds to win NFL Comeback Player of the Year

Jeff Hanisch-Imagn Images

Michael Penix Jr. has moved into the NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds conversation after making his 2026 debut in Week 3. Penix entered the season behind Tua Tagovailoa on Atlanta’s depth chart, while recovering from the torn ACL that ended his 2025 season. After missing the Falcons’ first two games, he took over against Green Bay and helped Atlanta earn its first win, completing 18 of 25 passes for 256 yards and one touchdown in a 35-14 victory.

He also showed some rust with an interception, but the overall performance provided a strong start to his comeback campaign. At +1500, Penix is now among the shorter-priced contenders, giving him a notable position in the NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds after just one regular-season appearance.

Jayden Daniels | +4000 odds to win NFL Comeback Player of the Year

Geoff Burke-Imagn Images

Jayden Daniels is a long-shot option in the NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds at +4000, although his current injury status makes his path to the award uncertain. Daniels is dealing with a second serious elbow injury in as many seasons and has already missed time in 2026. He returned to limited practice Wednesday, offering a potential indication that his absence may not be long term.

Before the injury, Daniels completed 56.9% of his passes for 260 yards and three touchdowns through two games while adding 100 rushing yards. If he can return and maintain productive passing and rushing numbers over the remainder of the season, the combination of statistical output and back-to-back injury recoveries would give his candidacy a strong foundation.

At +4000, Daniels is a potential value bet for bettors looking for a low-stakes sleeper with substantial upside if he returns to form.

Looking to bet on the NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds? Check out Oddspedia’s bet calculator and odds calculator!

📖 How to read NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds

Reading NFL Comeback Player of the Years odds is straightforward. Odds are usually presented in a format like +500 or -200. Positive odds (e.g., +500) show how much profit you’d make on a $100 bet. For example, a $100 bet at +500 odds would win you $500, plus your original $100 stake, totaling $600.

🤔 Who decides who wins the NFL Comeback Player of the Year Award?

For the NFL Comeback Player of the Year, there is a panel of AP sportswriters and broadcasters who regularly cover the NFL that ultimately decide which of the NFL CPOY candidates win the award. The award is then announced in the week leading up to the Super Bowl at the annual NFL Honors event.

The votes by the sportswriters and media members are cast at the end of the regular season and before the playoffs begin.

💰 How to bet on the NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds?

Placing a futures bet on the NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds is a five-step process that focuses on finding the best value.

1. Choose a Bookmaker and Compare Odds

Start by comparing CPOY odds across multiple legal sportsbooks (e.g., bet365, Stake). Odds for longshot candidates can vary significantly (+2000 vs. +2500), directly impacting your potential return. Selecting the best price ensures maximum value for your bet.

2. Sign Up and Deposit Funds

Complete the online registration with the chosen bookmaker, providing necessary personal details for identity verification. When depositing funds, consider any available welcome bonuses, as these offers can effectively reduce the risk on your initial portfolio investment.

3. Locate the Futures Market

Once logged in, navigate the bookmaker’s menu to find the market. The path is typically: NFL → Futures → Awards → Comeback Player of the Year (CPOY).

4. Select Your Bets and Enter Stakes

Identify your 3-4 preferred longshot players and click on their odds to add them to your bet slip. For each selection, enter the same wagering amount (stake) to create your diversified portfolio. It is crucial to place these as individual straight bets, not a parlay.

5. Review and Place the Bet

Before finalizing, review the bet slip to confirm the players, the locked-in odds, and the total amount risked. Once satisfied, submit the bets to secure your longshot odds for the entire NFL season.

  • $1,500 First Bet Offer
    Claim bonus

    Place your first bet with the token applied. If your first bet loses, you'll get up to $1,500 back in Bonus Bets. Add’l terms apply. Must be 21+ and located in U.S. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. BetMGM Sportsbook available in AZ, CO, DC, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MA, MD, MI, MS, NJ, NY, NC, PA, PR, OH, TN, VA, WV, WY only.

💸 Key Betting Strategies for NFL Comeback Player of the Year Odds

The following three strategies focus on maximizing value, managing risk and exploiting market inefficiencies across the NFL Season.

1. The Preseason Portfolio (Maximizing Odds)

The core of this strategy is maximizing initial value by placing multiple, small, diversified bets immediately after the odds are released. Your focus should be on 3 to 4 longshot players who are in situations offering high-turnaround opportunities (e.g., a key starter that was injured or missed part of the previous season). By selecting odds of +2000 or higher, you are constructing a portfolio that diversifies risk. If any one of your selections breaks out, the return on the small, pooled stake is massive.

  • Example: Placing $10 on four different players —Player A (+2500), B (+4000), C (+2000), and D (+3000) results in a total risk of $40.

2. Dynamic In-Season Monitoring and Adjustment (Identifying Breakouts)

The second stage involves rigorous monitoring of your longshots during the first half of the season (Weeks 1-8) to identify an odds-shortening breakout. You are tracking a sustained run of excellent production (e.g., a QB consistently throwing two or more touchdowns or an RB/WR averaging over 100 scrimmage yards per game). This breakout performance will dramatically shift the market and prepare you for the third strategic step. Volume and consistency are the only metrics that matter here, as they validate the initial preseason bet.

  • Example: Your $10 bet on Player B at +4000 sees their odds plummet to +300 after a dominant stretch where they lead all players in offensive metrics, confirming their status as an award contender.

3. The Calculated Mid-Season Hedge (Guaranteeing Profit)

This final, crucial strategy is pure risk management designed to lock in a guaranteed net profit. If your initial longshot has become a top favorite, you identify their closest rival and calculate the precise stake needed to place a bet on that rival. This is the “hedge bet.” The goal is to ensure that regardless of which of the two top candidates ultimately wins the award, you walk away with a guaranteed, significant return on your small initial investment, effectively taking risk off the table late in the season.

  • Example: With Player B at +300, and their rival, Player E, at +500, you calculate an $80 stake on Player E. This maneuver guarantees a net profit of at least $320 (if B wins) or $390 (if E wins), securing a massive return on your initial $40 risk.
  • $1,500 First Bet Offer
    Claim bonus

    Place your first bet with the token applied. If your first bet loses, you'll get up to $1,500 back in Bonus Bets. Add’l terms apply. Must be 21+ and located in U.S. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. BetMGM Sportsbook available in AZ, CO, DC, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MA, MD, MI, MS, NJ, NY, NC, PA, PR, OH, TN, VA, WV, WY only.

📈 NFL Comeback Player of the Year betting trends

When wagering on the NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds or any other NFL player award futures, it is always wise to research betting trends that have been established over the years. Here is a look at some key trends to consider before placing this season’s bets.

  • In 27 years, a quarterback has taken home the award 17 times.
  • Only one player has ever won the award on two occasions – Chad Pennington in 2006 with the Jets and in 2008 with the Dolphins.
  • In 2005, the award was given to both Teddy Bruschi and Steve Smith in the only case of there being co-winners.
  • Only four defensive players have ever won the award and only one has done so since 2008.
  • 12 of the last 17 NFL Comeback players of the Year have been quarterbacks.

🏆 Previous NFL Comeback Player of the Year winners by position

Position Winners
Quarterback 19
Running back 4
Wide receiver 3
Defensive end 2
Defensive tackle 1
Linebacker 1
Safety 1
Tight end 1
Placekicker 1
  • $1,500 First Bet Offer
    Claim bonus

    Place your first bet with the token applied. If your first bet loses, you'll get up to $1,500 back in Bonus Bets. Add’l terms apply. Must be 21+ and located in U.S. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. BetMGM Sportsbook available in AZ, CO, DC, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MA, MD, MI, MS, NJ, NY, NC, PA, PR, OH, TN, VA, WV, WY only.

  • Get $150 in Bonus Bets
    Offer applies automatically Claim bonus

    Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit RG-help.com. Call 1-888-789-7777 or visit ccpg.org/chat (CT). Hope is here. GamblingHelpLineMA.org or call (800) 327-5050 for 24/7 support (MA). Visit www.mdgamblinghelp.org (MD). Call 1-877-8HOPE-NY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY). 21+ (18+ D.C., KY, WY) and present in select states (for KS, in affiliation with Kansas Star Casino). First online real money wager only. $5 first deposit required. Bonus issued as nonwithdrawable bonus bets which expire 7 days after receipt. Restrictions apply. See terms at sportsbook.fanduel.com.

  • Bet $10 Get $200 in Bonus Bets Win or Lose
    Claim bonus

    Minimum $10 deposit required. Minimum odds -500 or greater. Bonus Bets wager excluded from returns. New customers only. T&CS, time limits and exclusions apply. Bets restrictions and T&C's apply. GAMBLING PROBLEM? CALL 1-800-GAMBLER (AZ, CO, IN, KY, LA, MD, NC, NJ, OH, VA) or 1-800-BETS OFF (IA). 21+ only(18+ in KY). Must be present in AZ/CO/IA/IN/KY/LA (select parishes)/NC/NJ/OH/VA.

Our best NFL betting sites

To make sure you get the most value on your NFL odds, go to the best NFL betting sites prior to placing your wagers throughout the season.

Sportsbook bonus Sportsbook promo code Sportsbook review
Stake Promo Code ODDSMAX Stake Review
bet365 Bonus Code ODDSPEDIA bet365 Review
Betway Promo Code N/A Betway Review

Want more insights on NFL betting markets?

Take a look at other Oddspedia Insights articles that give you everything you need in order to become a more informed bettor.

🏆 Previous NFL Comeback Player of the Year winners

Year CPOY Winner
2025 Christian McCaffrey
2024 Joe Burrow
2023 Joe Flacco
2022 Geno Smith
2021 Joe Burrow
2020 Alex Smith
2019 Ryan Tannehill
2018 Andrew Luck
2017 Keenan Allen
2016 Jordy Nelson
2015 Eric Berry
2014 Rob Gronkowski
2013 Philip Rivers

❓ NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds FAQs

Who won NFL Comeback Player of the Year in 2025?

Christian McCaffrey won the 2025 AP NFL Comeback Player of the Year award after returning from an injury-plagued 2024 season to reestablish himself as one of the league’s top offensive weapons. The San Francisco 49ers star totaled more than 2,100 yards from scrimmage and 17 total touchdowns, earning 31 of 50 first-place votes.

When will the NFL Comeback Player of the Year award be decided?

The winner of the NFL Comeback Player of the Year Award will be selected at the end of the NFL regular season. The winner is announced at the NFL Honors event, which takes place each year during Super Bowl week. All other individual awards are also presented at NFL Honors.

How are NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds determined?

NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds are determined by sportsbooks based on a player’s likelihood of returning to elite form after injury, illness, or a disappointing season. Oddsmakers consider factors such as past production, expected role, team success, and public betting interest when setting the market. The odds fluctuate throughout the season as players perform, suffer injuries, or emerge as legitimate award contenders.

Don't forget to share with friends
  • Facebook Icon
  • X Icon
  • Instagram Icon
  • Telegram Icon
    )    (       (       (      (            (       (
 ( /(    )\ )    )\ )    )\ )   )\ )         )\ )    )\ )     (
 )\())  (()/(   (()/(   (()/(  (()/(   (    (()/(   (()/(     )\
((_)\    /(_))   /(_))   /(_))  /(_))  )\    /(_))   /(_)) ((((_)(
  ((_)  (_))_   (_))_   (_))   (_))   ((_)  (_))_   (_))    )\ _ )\
 / _ \   |   \   |   \  / __|  | _ \  | __|  |   \  |_ _|   (_)_\(_)
| (_) |  | |) |  | |) | \__ \  |  _/  | _|   | |) |  | |     / _ \
 \___/   |___/   |___/  |___/  |_|    |___|  |___/  |___|   /_/ \_\