With the recent establishment of super-conferences and destruction of long-lasting leagues in college athletics, the future of collegiate competition is about to get a big shakeup. And, as the two remaining members of the Pac-12 look for a new home (and some ACC members seek greener pastures), what schools do their respective sports fans want to join their league?
Although whether their desires are realistic remains to be seen, it still can’t hurt to find out how fans feel about the shuffle. We surveyed 3,000 of them – and it’s safe to say they’ve definitely got feelings about the upcoming shifts.
How Fans Feel About the Great College Conference Shuffle
Many people who enjoy collegiate sports have been loyal fans to specific teams in specific conferences for years – even generations. For this reason, it can be quite threatening to think about how new teams entering the mix might shake up the kind of tradition and fair matchups that collegiate fandom is rooted in. Take this sentiment from one passionate fan:
I think it is absolutely terrible for all sports. College sports should be regional, so people can actually have the possibility of attending road games and having regional rivalries. It is terrible, terrible, terrible! TV money should not be how conferences are formed. It's an absolute embarrassment and travesty.
Or this one, put rather simply:
The loss of geographical cohesion is destroying college sports.
While these attitudes might sound slightly over the top, the reality is that some folks live and breathe their college teams, as in most cases they’re personally connected to the college itself as alumni or familial/generational fans.
Overall, it’s a close split – 55.3% of respondents approve of the mix-up and 44.7% raising their eyebrows. Even still, it’s worth noting that even those who can see why the moves are being made and the good it could bring to certain conferences, teams, or regions still don’t think it’s the best idea:
On the positive side, they can bring more exciting matchups and boost revenue. However, they also risk disrupting traditions and rivalries, and may affect student-athletes negatively with increased travel and demanding schedules.
Ooh – good point. But we’re guessing no one surveyed the student-athletes or their families. Just saying.
And America’s Most Wanted Team Overall Is…
All of this said, there’s nothing to stop the current dissolution of the Pac-12 and where competition in college sports is headed – so if your conference has no choice but to gain a team, it may as well be one with a good reputation or success rate, right?
We asked 3,000 American college football fans about their most wanted, pie-in-the-sky teams when it comes to absorbing one into their current teams’ conference. Florida State University, Ohio State, and Penn State were all in the top ten, likely because they all boast track records and popularity to be revered.
So who was number one? Not surprisingly, the University of Notre Dame – where 86% of fans surveyed want to remain independent. We can’t blame them, really, because if it ain’t broke (you know); however, if they had to join a conference, 57.1% of fans would prefer it be the Big Ten over the ACC (28.6%) and SEC (14.3%). Gotta keep those Irish fighting, right?
When analyzing what teams fans would rather see remain on their conferences’ sidelines, the University of Kansas, University of Arizona, and Mississippi State University were all in the least wanted category – but maybe that’s because they could be threats?
At the end of the day, if the fans we surveyed HAD to select a different conference for their school, they’d pick the SEC by a slim margin at 28.6%, only a bit higher than the Big Ten at 27.3%. Somehow, the Pac-12 still got 11.4% of the vote, even with the conference being two teams away from being defunct. Now we understand a love of the game, but it’s over, people.
Unpacking the Pac-12 Exodus: Fans’ Dream Teams
Regarding the breakdown of fans’ dream teams between basketball and football, there’s a host of heavy-hitters in each top ten: Duke, Gonzaga, Kentucky, and UConn are among the elite choices for basketball, while Notre Dame, Clemson, Texas, and Michigan are those for football. (Don’t worry, UCLA and Penn State made the favorites list for basketball and football as well, respectively.)
And the least wanted teams for each sport? Villanova, NC State, and Purdue all get the shaft, as do Baylor and the Wolverines out of Michigan for college basketball. College football fans would rather not come across Ole Miss, the Sooners from Oklahoma, Miami, and definitely not Oregon. (Are ducks really that threatening?)
Each of the college conferences have had their own identities for a long time – and now that they’re being shaken up a bit, a redefining within each sport will take place. The ACC would love to bring on Kentucky for hoops, and Florida State was in the top slot for football. Gonzaga is the top choice for Big 12 basketball fans, whereas the Big Ten had them tied with Kentucky for number one. Oklahoma was the most wanted by fans of Big 12 football, and Notre Dame won out for Big Ten fans.
Maybe you’re picking the bright side, thinking things like, “There have been some interesting moves. I wish whole conferences would have combined…we’ll see how things settle in the next year,” or maybe you’re feeling a bit more apocalyptic, believing it’s the “beginning of the end of the things that are great about college football.” Regardless of where you stand, the Great College Conference Shuffle is already well underway – and all you can do is tune in on game days to see how it shakes out.
The Impact of the Great College Conference Shuffle on Sports Betting
As fans eagerly await the reshuffling of college conferences, another group of enthusiasts is closely monitoring these developments with a different agenda in mind – sports bettors. With the ever-growing popularity of sports betting in the United States, events like the Great College Conference Shuffle have far-reaching implications for NFL and college football enthusiasts.
For many, following college sports is a natural extension of their passion for the NFL. The excitement of tracking NFL scores and NFL odds often extends to college football scores and college football odds. As conferences realign and teams shift, betting dynamics can change dramatically. This transformation presents unique opportunities for both fans and bettors alike.
Kentucky, a state with a rich sports tradition, is no stranger to this evolving landscape. With the rise of online sports betting, Kentucky betting sites have become hubs for sports enthusiasts to wager on their favorite teams and athletes. Savvy bettors are always on the lookout for the latest Kentucky betting offers and promotions to maximize their betting experience.
The connection between college sports and sports betting also extends to national platforms like DraftKings. The DraftKings Kentucky bonus, for instance, is an enticing offer that draws in both seasoned and novice bettors, adding another layer of excitement to the ever-changing world of sports.
Moreover, the interest in college conferences’ realignment has piqued the curiosity of sports bettors across the nation. They recognize that these changes can have a profound impact on the odds and outcomes of college football games. As the best US sportsbooks adapt to these shifts, bettors must stay informed to make informed wagers.
In a landscape where tradition and rivalries meet the ever-evolving world of sports betting, enthusiasts will be closely watching the outcome of the Great College Conference Shuffle, where both teams and bettors hope to come out as winners.
Dustin has been in the industry for 10-plus years, making various stops across Canada while gaining tremendous experience within the sports and betting landscape. His time with the well-established North American app theScore and theScore Bet was extremely valuable, giving him insight to help give you an edge on your wagers. Dustin is the host of Oddspedia’s popular show “Odds On,” discussing the NBA, NFL, and MLB betting markets with top handicappers from around the country. Dustin bets every single day at all of the top sportsbooks (FanDuel, DraftKings, BetMGM, and Caesars), and firmly believes you need to line shop in order to become a profitable bettor. If you want to see more of his plays, make sure to follow his Twitter @DustinSaracini. Follow for picks, strategies, and more.
Maryland's Mike Locksley was let go on October 21. Dave Aranda, Dave Doeren, and now Mike Norvell have also been let go. The next college football coach to be fired odds have a new favorite.
Explore the latest Doak Walker Award odds for the 2026 college football season, featuring the top favorites, sleeper picks, betting trends, past winners, and expert predictions for the nation's best running back.
We’ve analyzed the top receivers in college football and assessed their likelihood to win the Fred Biletnikoff award - given annually to the best wide receiver in CFB.
Why is Jeremiah Smith the favorite?
Can anybody overtake Smith?
Davey O'Brien Award odds for 2026 feature CJ Carr, Arch Manning and Dante Moore among the favorites. See the latest NCAA QB award odds, sleepers and predictions.
Breaking down Heisman Trophy odds for the 2026 college football season, including leading quarterbacks, breakout candidates, and shifting betting markets as performances and narratives evolve now.
2026 CFP projections feature Notre Dame, Miami and Texas as locks, with Alabama, Ole Miss and Boise State on the bubble. See our College Football Playoff bracket, CFP odds and longshot pick.
Ohio State, Georgia, Notre Dame, and Miami headline the latest NCAAF championship odds for the 2026 season. We break down the top contenders, sleeper picks, value bets, and where the best College Football Playoff futures stand right now.
College football fans would almost always prefer to be as close to the action as possible – but what does that cost? We’ve broken it all down using data on the top college football programs in the U.S.
As the college football season heats up, fans and bettors are closely watching college football win totals and analyzing college football total odds. These projections offer valuable insights into team performance and potential outcomes for the year. Let's look at some top-ranked teams and their college football projected win totals.
We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. You can manage your preferences and find out more by clicking the ‘Customise’ button below.